I am the Messenger vs The Messenger (#EdKennedy)

People often ask me why The Messenger is sometimes listed as I am the Messenger.







These two titles are exactly the same book, and the difference came only out of necessity in the USA. The book had already been out in Australia for more than a year, and the problem we had in America was that another book called Messenger was being released at the same time, with the same publisher. The author was Lois Lowry, author of The Giver. At the time, when I was asked to change it, I was pretty haughty (at least in my conjured-up internal conversations) and vowed that I didn’t care if fifty people were putting a book out with the same title. I even considered a more radical change to call it either The Joker or The Gambler. That would have meant a considerable rewrite, though, and that’s something you want to avoid when a book has already been published, as The Messenger was here at home. Still, with about eight years of hindsight, I quite like both titles. That said, if the same thing was to happen now, I’d probably be a bit more obstinate.



As a final piece of trivia, The Messenger was published as Der Joker in Germany. In some countries (Brazil is an example), the publisher used I am the Messenger as the title because they felt it sounded better or more poetic in that particular language.






23 likes ·   •  9 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on August 24, 2013 08:55
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Gina (new)

Gina One of my very favorite books!


message 2: by nicole (new)

nicole mine, too! :)


message 3: by Dani (new)

Dani LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS BOOK!


message 4: by Scotti (new)

Scotti So far, The Book Thief is one of my all time favorites, but now, I plan on reading this, too. Have read the Lowry book. Liked it.


message 5: by KimBear (new)

KimBear I've held off reading this one because I absolutely love The Book Thief...I know...sounds weird...but I just don't want to compare the two.


message 6: by Dana (new)

Dana Salman Wow, I didn't know it used to be called The Messenger, but I rather like I Am The Messenger better; the first title sounds like it would be about a Prophet or something. Either way, though, I LOVE this book, so touching and funny!


message 7: by Liset (new)

Liset LOOOOOVE IT!! It makes you cry, but also laugh so hard that you cant breath, it just touches your heart and stays in your mind.


message 8: by Maja (new)

Maja In sweden the title is Jokern, which means The Joker ;)


message 9: by Jill (new)

Jill I think I prefer I Am the Messenger to The Messenger. KimBear, no worries about comparing The Book Thief with this one. It's apples and oranges. I loved both...but for completely different reasons. Give it a go! You'll really like it. Having familiarity with Australians really helps on this one. I'm American, and if I'd not just spent a lot of time in in Australia and had an Aussie roommate, some of the text would have puzzled me a bit. However, reading it as is just brought me right back to Oz, which was wonderful!


back to top