Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

I know Cliff Notes editions don't get combined with the original works, but what about "CliffsComplete guides, the novel's "complete" text and a glossary appear side-by-side with coordinating numbered lines to help you understand unusual words and phrasing." ??

If they do get combined with the originals, I'm guessing the original author should also get top billing as well?

I feel like combining is correct, but thought I'd double check.

I would combine them with the original, with the original author listed first - as long as they contain the complete text. They are similar to Norton Critical Editions in this way - they have the entire text, plus additional material.

Lobstergirl wrote: "I would combine them with the original, with the original author listed first - as long as they contain the complete text. They are similar to Norton Critical Editions in this way - they have the..."

Agreed.

That's what I thought - thanks.