Catching up on Classics (and lots more!) discussion
Other Challenges Archive
>
Sam's Challenge
date
newest »



Thanks Sarah! You're probably the first Eddings fan I've met here! I'm doing a re-read of my Eddings books, but for the first time in English (I read them in German when I was a teenager). I'm super excited for the Steinbeck since I enjoyed Grapes of Wrath and Cannery Row immensely.

I just FINALLY read Grapes of Wrath last month. It was a very good book.


I´m pretty big fantasy fan but those Edding books just didn´t do it for me :(
I´m going to make some kind of fantasy challenge for myself this year too!

I´m pretty big fantasy fan but those Edding books just didn´t do it for me :(
I´m going to make some kind of fantasy challenge for myself thi..."
Oh great, are you going to share your reading list? I'd definitely want to check it out :)
Eddings definitely has his flaws, but was just the right mix of Disney princess style clishés and humour to help me survive my early teenage years. I take him with a grain of salt these days.

Yes my fantasy list is in here:https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Those are maybe not the most interesting ones but they are mostly from the older side of my TBR-list and mostly randomly picked so I get them read! :) But there are couple I´m really looking forward to, like the Abercrombie book!
Who’s afraid of Virginia Woolf? I am. My trip with Mrs. Dalloway to The Light House was brutal. I have read several of Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes, but still have a few left to read. I am thinking of finishing the series this next year. As for East of Eden, it’s my favorite Steinbeck.

Yes my fantasy list is in here:https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/......"
Oh yes! I read those first (the Elenium and the Tamuli), and prefer them too. Although many readers seem to see them as rip-offs of Belgariad and Malloreon, I never saw it that way.
Nice list you made, but I must admit I don't know half of the authors. I recently read American Gods and enjoyed it a lot, but was also confused. I couldn't get into Dune when I tried it last year, but I'm determined to try again, I still own the copy. Abercrombie is a huge name these days, but I haven't gotten around to reading a single book of his. Good luck with your challenges and happy reading!

Ouch, Bob; I've had my trouble with capricious Mrs. Dalloway myself, but I am fascinated with Woolf and have acquired two other of her books meanwhile (Orlando and A Room of One's Own). And of course I'm intrigued to finally get to that famous play.
I too have read almost half of the Holmes books and stories, but was on a break for too long now. I really like the old fellow :)
Have you read Cannery Row? I was so astonished how different it was from Grapes of Wrath! This fact made me fall for Steinbeck a little more and I'm so excited to read more of his work. I've his take on the Arthurian legends on my wishlist as well, can say anything about it?

I tried to read "Mrs Dalloway" right after reading Dostoevsky's "Notes From the Underground." These two books followed each other as monthly reads earlier this year for this group.
It was brutal to try to read those two books back to back. I gave up and CNF "Mrs Dalloway." This experience left me traumatized and reluctant to tangle with Ms. Woolf!

East of Eden is also quite different from Grapes of Wrath and Cannery Row. It's almost hard to think all of them as the same writer. But all three are quite wonderful. Dune is really good but I found that I had trouble connecting with the characters because I connect emotionally and Dune is a book about achieving control through intellect. It's actually a really cool book but I did struggle a bit with that aspect.

I´m also afraid of Virginia Woolf but I have only read Mrs Dalloway and my policy is usually give 2 chances. So maybe some other book still, but not sure which one.
I have read couple Steinbecks and liked them (East of Eden I read this year), so I want more of him. Grapes of Wrath is next for me (when I have time ;) ). But those Arthurian legends sounds very interesting, I really want to hear more about them!
I´m a little afraid of the Dune...I´m not scifi person (even I love fantasy) and I have heard that it´s difficult one. And if you Sarah struggled I´m sure I will!

East of Eden is also quite different from Grapes of Wrath and Cannery Row. It's almost ..."
Now I'm even more intrigued! Steinbeck, you chameleon!
I think I understand your problems with Dune and I'm afraid it is the same thing that happened when I tried to read it. So maybe it won't get better when I try again..

I´m also afraid ..."
I haven't read it yet, but since Sarah recommends it, I'd vote for Orlando, and it does sound fascinating. A person who is constantly reborn in different times and places - and bodies. This could be really beautiful.


I know that is one of the reasons I want to read it. There is also a creepy-looking silent movie adapation out there, and I mean to watch it after reading. Thank you!


I have East of Eden on my shortlist, but not my official one.. :D"
I have some kind of shortlist as well - it is very long!

All in all an enjoyable read with some excellent comic relief.

Congrats on completing your first book and good luck with your next choices :)

Congrats on completing your first book and good luck with your next choices :)"
Thanks Pink!
Sam wrote: "I read my first book for this challenge! King of the Murgos by David Eddings was a re-read for me, but this time I read the original version and not the translation. It ..."
I went on a David Eddings kick a few years back and enjoyed his different series. I agree "All in all an enjoyable read with some excellent comic relief. "
I went on a David Eddings kick a few years back and enjoyed his different series. I agree "All in all an enjoyable read with some excellent comic relief. "

I actually prefer the books about Sparrowhawk, but I'd have to reread them too to put my finger on it. Maybe it is just because they were my introduction to Eddings. How did you discover him, Kathy? I got the books from my best friend, she had all of them. We loved to read together.
I taught high school mathematics for years, and one of my students recommended that I read them.
Books mentioned in this topic
King of the Murgos (other topics)King of the Murgos (other topics)
King of the Murgos (other topics)
Danton's Death (other topics)
The Red and the Black (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
David Eddings (other topics)David Eddings (other topics)
David Eddings (other topics)
Old School
1. Victor Hugo: The Man Who Laughs2. Georg Büchner: Danton's Death3. Stendhal: The Red and the BlackNew School
4. John Steinbeck: East of Eden5. Edward Albee: Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?6. Max Frisch: AndorraWild Cards
7. Diverse: Tintenfass Nr. 228. David Eddings: King of the Murgos9. David Eddings: Demon Lord of Karanda10. David Eddings: Sorceress of Darshiva11. David Eddings: The Seeress of Kell12. Friedrich Hebbel: Herodes und Mariamnepurged—not countedAlternates
A-1. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle: The Complete Sherlock Holmes
A-2. Gottfried Keller: Novelas de Zúrichpurged—not counted