2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion

Eleanor Wish is back in Harry's life. Were you suspicious of her role throughout the story? Your thoughts about their relationship?

Yes, I was suspicious until the last chapter because she was in Las Vegas and seemed to be slightly shady. I really did expect her to have run out on him or to sell him out somehow.

I was suspicious until Harry had to rescue her from the Samoans. She could have set the whole thing up, but I didn't think she had. At that point I started believing the things she was telling him.

I was suspicious of her, too, but also found her tragic. She'd really screwed up her life.

I wasn't suspicious of her. Her desire for vengeance led her down the wrong path, but she was never a bad or evil person.

That said, I do not think she is the right person for Harry. Once again, she is too damaged and he is in his "rescue the damsel in distress" mode.

Our Harry, being himself.

Yeah, he really needs to get over it and find someone healthy!

I think he's trying to save his mother, over and over again.

Jonetta wrote: "I think he's trying to save his mother, over and over again."

Yes!

Good point.

I too was suspicious of her right until the end...I felt like she was too damaged and would somehow abandon Harry with a betrayal.

I agree, Eleanor is not who I would pick for Harry.

I didn't like her attitude during their initial sit-down at Caesar's. But she then showed none of that resentment when Harry visited her at home, or for their rest of the story. I generally like Eleanor and I'm glad they're back on.