Around the World in 80 Books discussion
Group Reads Discussions
>
Discussion for We Need New Names
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Diane , Armchair Tour Guide
(new)
Jan 15, 2021 06:53PM

reply
|
flag


The depiction of a childhood in a war zone was sad and disturbing.

will wait for others to finish before I pen down more of my thoughts.




Around the 46-48% of the book the author talks about how a group of extremists come to a white family's house and capture them.
After that section the author talks about "burying bodies", and "crosses" and how everyone wept. "Many people from Paradise wept". And she mentions "GodKnows is dead".
This doesn't make any sense. Can someone please explain? Are the blacks rioting against the whites? How come blacks have died here? Sholdn't it have been the opposite?


I purchased a used copy months ago and have yet to start it. Still trying to catch up on my January reading. Maybe we can start reading around the same time.

Around the 46-48% of the book the author talks about how a group of extremists come to a white family's house and capture them.
After that section the aut..."
This Atlantic article describes the reign of Robert Mugabe, who I'm pretty sure is the president referred to in the book.
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/...
Look into the history of Robert Mugabe, he was the leader during the time period of the book. There was a lot of unrest, and there was a lot of violence against the white landowners, who tried to keep their lands after Rhodesia became Zimbabwe.

First and foremost, there is the identity crisis of the immigrant. What do you keep from your old culture, and what do you change to assimilate? This is mostly seen through the eyes of the teenage narrator Darling, but it extends to her Zimbabwean aunt and her Ghanaian uncle, and especially to Tshaka Zulu, the elderly Zimbabwean her aunt takes care of, who tragically faces an identity crisis in his dementia.
A subportion of the immigrant identity crisis is devoted to those who stay beyond their legal visas because they appreciate the opportunities of their new country, even as they know they are shackled to that country and can never return home to see friends and family because they may never have their opportunity again.
Second is the identity crisis of age, which affects every character. What do you keep from your childhood, and what do you put away? What happens when you aren't allowed a childhood, such as Darling's friend Chipo? I loved how Bulawayo humanized each of the kids in Darling's gang -- especially the hardened leader who reacted so well to her father. It was interesting to see even in passing what decisions they made as they grew older.
Finally, there is the identity crisis of country. Bulawayo doesn't focus as much attention on the US as she does on her native land. Here, she castigates Mugabe's terrible Operation Murambatsvina that left Paradise in ruins, and the controversial 2008 election that left the country in turmoil. In one awful vignette, Darling's gang watches as a white couple learns that the Rhodesia they knew as children has moved on. But after Darling leaves, she learns from a friend that it's the ones left behind that have to pick up the pieces and find a way to move forward -- to determine who they want to be as a country.

The realities these children have to deal with are very different from what my own childhood was like, but it's still possible to relate to how they think and feel. In particular, Darling's attitude toward her father when he returned reminded me of my own discomfort at visiting my great grandmother, when she was too old and senile to remember me anymore.
One of the interesting things about the child's view is that as an adult, you can read the adult view of things between the lines. When I got to the clotheshanger episode, I had to put down the book twice before I could finally make it through the chapter, and when they were discovered by an adult towards the end, I knew exactly how that woman was feeling even though she didn't say a word.
Books mentioned in this topic
Tomorrow I'll Be Twenty (other topics)We Need New Names (other topics)