SA Book & Challenge Lovers discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
15 views
Retired Topics > The Patchwork Challenge (Nominations)

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lu (last edited Jul 17, 2010 01:09PM) (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
As the name implies this is a Challenge made up of everyone's input and ideas.

How it works?

Each person can choose 5 "reading goals" they want to add. But you can only list your 5 until Monday afternoon (19th). I will then put everything together and tada we have a new challenge :)

Still a little confused?

Just have a look at the type of things others nominate and you can jump right in.

This challenge will last one year and start on the 20th this month.

Oh and please try and make it do-able. Not something like "read 50 books starting with the letter S".
Try and keep it to 1 book per nomination if possible. Also please try not to nominate something tailored to your needs: Read 2 Dan Brown books etc.

Have fun!

UPDATE: Only nominate 5. I'll have a update nominations list and just go from there :)


message 2: by Lu (last edited Jul 17, 2010 08:41AM) (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
I'm up for a real challenge!

1. Read a book with your Name (Tie in with http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/3...)

2. Read 2 books with the word "love" in the title

3. Read 2 authors with a colour as their surname example Holly Black

4. Read 2 books that were released in 2010

5. Read a book that was made into a movie OR television show.

6. Read a book by a author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan


message 3: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments Good idea Lu! Maar jy het al die goeies alreeds gevat!


message 4: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments Let me think... Hmmm!


message 5: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Hehe no rush, add them as you think of them :)


message 6: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments 1. Read 1 book starting with each letter of my name.

2. Read 1 book by a South-African author.

3. Read 5 "next in the series" books released in
2010 (this one is sneaky, cause if anything is
released and I have not read the series, I can
read the books before that one first! Hehe).

4. Read 2 non-fiction books.

5. Read 5 non-vampire books (I'm binging at vampire
books at the moment, so this would be a real
challenge!)

6. Read a book that was made into a movie or
television show (thanks Lu!)


message 7: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments 5. Read 5 non-vampire books (I'm binging ON vampire
books at the moment, so this would be a real
challenge!)


message 8: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Mmm Sonette you are confusing me a little

Does nr 1 mean each person reads their name? OR yours?

Nr6 is the same as mine?


message 9: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments Hehe! I know Lu, couldn't think of another one! I cheated. Anyway, number 1, everyone reads their own name!


message 10: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith Cool idea!

1. Read a book by a South African author

2. Start a new series (so read at least 2 books)

3. Read a book to learn something new (this can be fiction or non-fiction, eg. you could read a novel or a non-fiction work about Victorian England.) Emphasis on NEW - choose a topic you know little or nothing about.

4. Try a genre you normally avoid (I've tried this, and it can be really cool, especially if you 'swap' genres with someone else, and you chat about what you thought of each others books)

5. Read a random book - pick a book that you've never heard of, by an author you don't know of.

6. Read a book with an unusual narrator - a young child, an animal, an AI, a group narrator, etc. Vampires, werewolves, fairies, etc. DO NOT count.


message 11: by Lu (last edited Jul 17, 2010 12:36PM) (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Good ideas guys!

Sonette do you mind nominating 5? Long story to follow:


message 12: by Lauren (last edited Jul 17, 2010 11:28AM) (new)

Lauren Smith Oh, now I understand! I thought you would have to choose one person's set of 6. Does this mean the challenge has 18 different steps so far (some of them with multiple books)? If I use my name for number 7, that already means reading 31 books, and others might add more.

Perhaps you could just pick 6 (or some other number) from the list? Or get a point for each one that you complete? Otherwise it could be very long.

My number 1: Read a book that's been on your shelf for a long time ("a long time" is relative, so just pick one of the unread books that's been on your shelf the longest).


message 13: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
I thought there might have been a misunderstanding :)

It does seem to be getting long lol. Maybe i should make it a year challenge?

What do you guys think?


message 14: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith The problem is that each step can have multiple books, and the list could get very long. Also, some people might not be able to do certain challenges. For example, I don't often read series, so it could be ages before I read 5 "next in series" books. Reading two books released in 2010 might not be do-able if you don't have access to a good library or don't buy new books.

If you pick a fixed number of steps to do, it'll be easier to complete the challenge by the end of the year. If you get a point for every step you complete, we can have rankings.


message 15: by Lauren (last edited Jul 17, 2010 11:46AM) (new)

Lauren Smith Oh, there's also a lot of crossover with some challenges. For example I could read Love Hurts, a 2010 publication by Lauren Lilac, a South African author. It's a genre I normally avoid, and it's random because I haven't heard of the title or author. Does that mean I've completed 8 steps, or do I have to pick just one?


message 16: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
I see what you are saying Lauren :(

How about this. We Renominate. 5 each. We try and keep each nomination to 1 book if possible (some might require reading another book etc).

I hazard a guess in saying only 6 of us will nominate. So 30 books + the few that can't be avoided.

We might not be able to finish it, but we can give it a hard try! :)

We can also have ratings :)

Oh and you can only use a book in one category!

How does that sound? Or am i completely off the plot lol?


message 17: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith That's a lot better, and ja, I don't think you'll end up with that many nominations.
I think a challenge is better if you have a decent chance of finishing though, or you can accumulate points (as with the Read Your Name challenge).

I'll leave my 6 as is, and just take out the series one, as that involves 2 books.

This is a lot like my Random Reading Goals in the reading goals folder, but I guess I can just add any of these to that :)


message 18: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Should we make it a year challenge then?


message 19: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS SO FAR:

1. Read a book with your Name (Tie in with http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/3028...)
2. Read a book with the word "love" in the title
3. Read a author with a colour as a surname example Holly Black
4. Read a book that was released in 2010
5. Read a book by a author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan
6. Read a book by a South African author
7. Read a book to learn something new (this can be fiction or non-fiction, eg. you could read a novel or a non-fiction work about Victorian England.) Emphasis on NEW - choose a topic you know little or nothing about.
8. Try a genre you normally avoid (I've tried this, and it can be really cool, especially if you 'swap' genres with someone else, and you chat about what you thought of each others books)
9. Read a random book - pick a book that you've never heard of, by an author you don't know of.
10. Read a book with an unusual narrator - a young child, an animal, an AI, a group narrator, etc. Vampires, werewolves, fairies, etc. DO NOT count.


message 20: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith I guess it depends on how many steps there are. 10 or 15 books isn't too bad. More than that and I'd say make it a year.

Otherwise, I'm still in favour of a point system. It would also mean that there can be as many steps as you want, so you could extend the cut-off date and give more people a chance to add to the list.

Are there any rules for nomination? I think that the challenge should at least be applicable to anyone - something you can tailor to your own reading patterns. For example, don't make a Dan Brown challenge, or a sci fi challenge, because some people might not be interested in those things.


Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
Im Loving this challenge, but I also think that it should be longer (a year perhaps) otherwise I don't think we would have enough time to get all the challenges done. It would also be very cool if we could make a score card that we could update as we go along just to make it interesting. My competetive nature is coming out :D


message 22: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Ok agreed then, a year challenge and a points system :)

I hear what you are saying about the nominations being applicable to everyone. I'll keep a eye out, and at the end of the nominations if anyone thinks a nomination is too tailored and won't really work we can change it :)


message 23: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith Ok, cool :)

Also just wondering about challenges like your number 5 challenge Lu - Read a book by an author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan. It's impossible to search for a book based on those criteria, so unless you already have something in mind, it could be really frustrating.


message 24: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
I was thinking about that too, I think when I post the final results I'll give a few suggestions by each one. And if anyone needs more help they can ask and we can pool our brains :)

I'm sure those Authors are out there... somewhere lol

Sound good?

I'm sure i'll need a little help coming up with a book to read by some of them aswell! I know Lauren (the other one lol) will think of some hard ones :P


message 25: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith That's a good plan :)


message 26: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Oooh i found some:
Sara Shepard
Morin, Marie
Jean Johnson
Ginger Garrett
Mari Mancusi
Sydney Salter
Fannie Flagg

I'm sure someone on the internet has made a list somewhere. I will track them down when i'm not sleeping on the keyboard! :P

So excited for this challenge to start already!


message 27: by Lauren (Sugar & Snark) (last edited Jul 17, 2010 01:29PM) (new)

Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
I also agree with the Other (brighter :D) Lauren we should keep the challenges general so that everyone no matter their reading preferences can be included in the challenge.

Here are my nominations-

1) Favourite Colour- That predominant colour of the book cover should be your favourite colour. e.g. red is my favourite colour so
Lover Mine (Black Dagger Brotherhood, #8) by J.R. Ward

2) One Word- The title of the book should only have one word in it e.g. Wings, Lolita, Fallen

3) Double Title- Find two books by different authors with the same name. e.g. Scandal
Scandal  by Carolyn Jewel Scandal by Amanda Quick

4) Set in a City- The story is set and revolves around 1 major city e.g Chicago Land Vampire Series or Sex and The City

5) Dear Diary- Book written in the form of someone’s diary or has the word diary in the title e.g. Bridget Jones Diary or Vampire Diaries.


message 28: by Lu (last edited Jul 17, 2010 01:38PM) (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS SO FAR:

1. Read a book with your Name (Tie in with http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/3...)
2. Read a book with the word "love" in the title
3. Read a author with a colour as a surname example Holly Black
4. Read a book that was released in 2010
5. Read a book by a author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan
6. Read a book by a South African author
7. Read a book to learn something new (this can be fiction or non-fiction, eg. you could read a novel or a non-fiction work about Victorian England.) Emphasis on NEW - choose a topic you know little or nothing about.
8. Try a genre you normally avoid (I've tried this, and it can be really cool, especially if you 'swap' genres with someone else, and you chat about what you thought of each others books)
9. Read a random book - pick a book that you've never heard of, by an author you don't know of.
10. Read a book with an unusual narrator - a young child, an animal, an AI, a group narrator, etc. Vampires, werewolves, fairies, etc. DO NOT count.
11) Favourite Colour- That predominant colour of the book cover should be your favourite colour. e.g. red is my favourite colour.
12) One Word- The title of the book should only have one word in it e.g. Wings, Lolita, Fallen
13) Double Title- Find two books by different authors with the same name. e.g. Scandal and Scandal
14) Set in a City- The story is set and revolves around 1 major city e.g Chicago Land Vampire Series or Sex and The City
15) Dear Diary- Book written in the form of someone’s diary or has the word diary in the title e.g. Bridget Jones Diary or Vampire Diaries.


message 29: by Sonette (new)

Sonette | 384 comments Okay here are my new nominations:

1. Read a book by a South-African author;
2. Read a non-fiction book;
3. Read a book written by a woman for woman;
4. Read a autobiography;
5. Read a book with a Country name in the title.


message 30: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Thanks Sonette! :)

You just need a new nr 1 :(

Sorry to keep doing this to you!


message 31: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS SO FAR:

1. Read a book with your Name (Tie in with http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/3...)
2. Read a book with the word "love" in the title
3. Read a author with a colour as a surname example Holly Black
4. Read a book that was released in 2010
5. Read a book by a author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan
6. Read a book by a South African author
7. Read a book to learn something new (this can be fiction or non-fiction, eg. you could read a novel or a non-fiction work about Victorian England.) Emphasis on NEW - choose a topic you know little or nothing about.
8. Try a genre you normally avoid (I've tried this, and it can be really cool, especially if you 'swap' genres with someone else, and you chat about what you thought of each others books)
9. Read a random book - pick a book that you've never heard of, by an author you don't know of.
10. Read a book with an unusual narrator - a young child, an animal, an AI, a group narrator, etc. Vampires, werewolves, fairies, etc. DO NOT count.
11) Favourite Colour- That predominant colour of the book cover should be your favourite colour. e.g. red is my favourite colour.
12) One Word- The title of the book should only have one word in it e.g. Wings, Lolita, Fallen
13) Double Title- Find two books by different authors with the same name. e.g. Scandal and Scandal
14) Set in a City- The story is set and revolves around 1 major city e.g Chicago Land Vampire Series or Sex and The City
15) Dear Diary- Book written in the form of someone’s diary or has the word diary in the title e.g. Bridget Jones Diary or Vampire Diaries.
16. ---
17. Read a non-fiction book;
18. Read a book written by a woman for woman;
19. Read a autobiography;
20. Read a book with a Country name in the title.


Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
I know I used up all my chances but I have another one which could be fun if you are looking for a filler-
A book with an animal in the title e.g. Water for Elephants or The Dog that Barked in the Night


message 33: by Shannon SA (new)

Shannon SA (shannonsa) Cool! I love challenges! (Definitely have a point system!) My 5 nominations:
1. Read a classic (e.g. Jane Austen, Charles Dickens)
2. Read an award winning book (e.g. Man Booker, Orange, Newbery, Costa, Pulitzer)
3. Read a book whose author shares your birth month (e.g. I was born in April; so were William Shakespeare and Barbara Kingsolver)
4. Read a book from the BBC Big Read top 100 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/bigread/top100.s...)
5. Read a book not originally written in English - read the book in English or in the language in was written in (e.g. Anna Karenina (Russian), Triomf (Afrikaans))


message 34: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Love it Shannon! Thanks for taking part :)


message 35: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS SO FAR:

1. Read a book with your Name (Tie in with http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/3...)
2. Read a book with the word "love" in the title
3. Read a author with a colour as a surname example Holly Black
4. Read a book that was released in 2010
5. Read a book by a author who's name and surname starts with the same letter, example Rick Riordan
6. Read a book by a South African author
7. Read a book to learn something new (this can be fiction or non-fiction, eg. you could read a novel or a non-fiction work about Victorian England.) Emphasis on NEW - choose a topic you know little or nothing about.
8. Try a genre you normally avoid (I've tried this, and it can be really cool, especially if you 'swap' genres with someone else, and you chat about what you thought of each others books)
9. Read a random book - pick a book that you've never heard of, by an author you don't know of.
10. Read a book with an unusual narrator - a young child, an animal, an AI, a group narrator, etc. Vampires, werewolves, fairies, etc. DO NOT count.
11) Favourite Colour- That predominant colour of the book cover should be your favourite colour. e.g. red is my favourite colour.
12) One Word- The title of the book should only have one word in it e.g. Wings, Lolita, Fallen
13) Double Title- Find two books by different authors with the same name. e.g. Scandal and Scandal
14) Set in a City- The story is set and revolves around 1 major city e.g Chicago Land Vampire Series or Sex and The City
15) Dear Diary- Book written in the form of someone’s diary or has the word diary in the title e.g. Bridget Jones Diary or Vampire Diaries.
16. ---
17. Read a non-fiction book;
18. Read a book written by a woman for woman;
19. Read a autobiography;
20. Read a book with a Country name in the title.
21. Read a classic (e.g. Jane Austen, Charles Dickens)
22. Read an award winning book (e.g. Man Booker, Orange, Newbery, Costa, Pulitzer)
23. Read a book whose author shares your birth month (e.g. I was born in April; so were William Shakespeare and Barbara Kingsolver)
24. Read a book from the BBC Big Read top 100 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/bigread/top100.shtm...)
25. Read a book not originally written in English - read the book in English or in the language in was written in (e.g. Anna Karenina (Russian), Triomf (Afrikaans))


message 36: by Lauren (Sugar & Snark) (last edited Jul 18, 2010 11:31AM) (new)

Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
We need to start thinking about the rules. For example can one book overlap and cover 2 challenges? I was thinking about reading The Book Thief which is narrated by death and set during the holocaust which would cover A book with an unusual narrator and learning something new ( about the holocaust) Or do we have to have 1 book per challenge?


message 37: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith I asked Lu about this a few posts above - she said one book can only be used for one challenge I'm afraid.

I was also thinking about completing multiple challenges in one fell swoop :)


Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
Damn I should have read all the posts I was starting to get really creative with my list! :D


message 39: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith Hehe, yeah, I try and do it with all my other challenges and reading goals. It's getting really hard though.


message 40: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Lol no cheating! :P


Lauren (Sugar & Snark) | 1262 comments Mod
Oh come on! Its note cheating its bending the rules ;) That list is getting LONG! We have to do something or we will have to make it a 2 year challenge LOL


message 42: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Oh miss i have read 70 books this year, i don't think it should be a problem :P


message 43: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Smith The Exclusive Books Sale is coming up soon! Fanatics preview on 28 July - let's hope we can pick up some challenge books :)
I should probably print a list of the challenges to take with...


message 44: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Oh no I'm probably going to miss the sale :(
(going on a dig). But I'll probably just end up broke anyway lol


message 45: by Shannon SA (new)

Shannon SA (shannonsa) Lauren wrote: "The Exclusive Books Sale is coming up soon! Fanatics preview on 28 July - let's hope we can pick up some challenge books :)
I should probably print a list of the challenges to take with..."


Oh great, their sale is one of my many weaknesses!


message 46: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
I'm a bit worried here. We only have 25 nominations. I would like to have atleast 30. Niecole, Emma you guys out there? This starts tomorrow and I just want everything set up by later tonight :(


message 47: by Heather (new)

Heather Tribe (tribefox) Ok here goes:
1. Read a sports themed book.
2. Read 3 books with 2 elements on the front cover. E.g. The ocean and sky= water and air
3.Read 1 book with 2 types of animals on the cover
4. Read 1 book that has "his" or "her" in the title
5.Read 1 book from the Victorian era


message 48: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
Thank you so much Heather!

Your nominations are all I needed :) You are a star!

Nr 2 will just have to be 1 book, but other than that its perfect :)


message 49: by Lu (new)

Lu | 12672 comments Mod
NOMINATIONS ARE NOW CLOSED.

THIS CHALLENGE STARTS TOMORROW 20TH JULY.

HERE IS THE OFFICIAL THREAD

SUGGESTIONS THREAD

POINTS THREAD


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.