Harry Potter discussion
Questions
>
so...
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Tess
(last edited Aug 25, 2016 02:13PM)
(new)
Dec 08, 2007 08:42AM
in the 4th book is says cho is a year ahead of harry, but in the 7th, he goes back to hogwarts for the horcux and she's there, ditching class. You can only go to hogwarts for 7 years, so....?
reply
|
flag
gosh some people make mistakes duh okay Jk. made one no one's perfect
Was she ditching class? I thought that as a member of Dumbledore's Army she was told that the trio had returned, so like Fred and George, she had just returned to help fight Voldemort.
Wow, I never even realized that. Haha. Thanks, Tess.
to mckenzey:but she was there when he got there. then they told the rest of the DA to come...
Maybe ginny or neville asked her for help...
yeah maybe.
I thought that might come up. I don't know, that was just an idea.
cho got held back! kidding, i hv no clue why
i think she had also kept the fake galleon and when she realized it had gone hot she must have cum back to the castle along with the others..
i still think it would've been funny if she'd been held back...
hah. never really liked her anyways... no offense meant. :)
