date
newest »

message 1:
by
Reshma
(new)
Dec 28, 2011 12:37AM

reply
|
flag



Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)

Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)"
Reviews are so you can say whether or not you like the book. Whats the point if your not honest about whether you liked it or not?





Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)"read my comment further down. This is how the author learns. I'm glad that you thought the book was good.
Reviews are so you can say whether or not..."

Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)"
I'm glad they didn't, otherwise I wouldn't have found out how so many readers have felt cheated over the last book. Just as I think Eugiene grows up and takes a step forward, Mead creates something that makes her take ten paces back.
Apparently she's done something similar in all of her other books, and I can't help but wonder why she keeps doing it?
This was the only series by Mead that I was relatively interested in--and I can't believe I'm saying this because I've always tried finishing a series--but I'm not going to read the final book.
As a reader we are putting our trust in an author to satisfy us in our need for a story. From reading all the reviews--the good and the bad--I've found out that not only does it not have an ending, but from what I've heard and read, it feels like it was put together in a hurry and hasn't even ticked one box. The death of the baddies? Nope. A HEA on the romantic front? Nope, not quite. The main character slowly developing and becoming a better person? Certainly not!
If the author can't be bothered about their own story, then why should I?



Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)"
I'm glad they didn't, otherwise I wouldn't ha..."
Well if you don't like her books...here is a thought.....don't read them simple as that, if you have so much bad things to say about them :)



Maybe you should keep your bad reviews to yourself next time :)"
I'm glad they didn't, otherwise ..."
I have to admit that I don't quite understand where you're coming from but OK.
As I said before, I read the previous books and enjoyed reading them, however I was also saying that I very much doubt that I will read the final book as I have talked to many people who have said that the last book was a weak effort to close the series.
What do you think is more helpful to a writer? A critique that focuses on the good points or the bad points? This website is so you can discuss books and yet I find it very odd that you're so dead set against anyone having any negative opinion on a book. Have you not read a book where you had mixed feelings towards it? That is exactly how I felt about this series.
Although I don't agree with your opinion because even though I disliked them, I had to read lots of books for College, I also find it funny that you're not following your own advice: if you don't like our comments then don't read/reply to them.